Saturday, 8 March 2014

Typical Boiler Tube Failure Analysis

Tube failures occur due to the �Overheating� and the �Plastic Flow� conditions associated with restricted flow of water in side of the particular tube facing failure.

Such failures are generally of two types:
(i)           Overheating in �Short Duration�
(ii)          Overheating over a �Long Period�

Careful examination of the failed tube section reveals whether the failure is on account of rapid acceleration in the tube wall temperature or it is on account of a long term gradual build up/ accumulation of the cause of failure.


(a)      Short Duration Over-Heating: -
When conditions causing a rapid metal temperature elevation at local spot occur, a violent rupture results. The �Plastic � Flow� phenomena of �Carbon Steel� materials at temperatures between: 700 0C � 800 0C is the cause of such occurrences.
Photograph 1

Interruption/ Restriction, in the water circulation by some blockage in tube leads to such failures, as the tube metal gets exposed to direct flames in such cases.




(b)      Long Duration Over-Heating: -
�Long Term� conditions finally lead to a tube leak; wrinkled or bulged external surfaces are observed in such cases. Such appearance is caused by long term �Creep Failure� causing by repetitive scale formation, which leads to �Overheating�, thus �Swelling� the surface, forming a Bulge or Blister, visually observable minor fissures, etc. on external surfaces. Photograph 2 given hereunder illustrates the same.
Photograph 2

(c)       Some Suggestions for Avoiding Such Failures: -
It is recommended that the quality of the �Boiler Feed Water� for boilers operating at 21 Kg/ cm2   (g) should be as per the annexure �A� attached herewith.

It is also recommended that the �Blow Down Time� & duration should be observed as per the annexure �B� attached herewith.

Blow Down must also be conducted on regular basis (When Boiler is in Low Steaming Stage) from side wall, rear & front wall headers; so that sludge accumulation in these headers may be avoided; which otherwise would rise in furnace tubes creating conditions for circulation restrictions/ blockage, thus overheating at local spots.

At times, foreign matters get left behind during the erection. Such happenings may be avoided by carefully examining tubes/ headers after fitting the same by a suitable method, such as, ball test/ by passing water & observing flow at the other end (where possible). Anyhow, these precautions should be taken before the firing of the Boiler.


ANNEXURE �A�

Sr.
Feed Water


1
Hardness, Max. (as Ca CO3)                       mg/L
:
10
2
pH at 25 0C                                            
:
8.8 to 9.2
3
Oxygen, Max.                                          mg/L
:
0.1
4
Total Iron                                               mg/L
:
0.100
5
Copper, Max.                                          mg/L
:
0.05
6
Total Dissolved Solids, Max.                       mg/L
:
200


Sr.
Boiler Water


1
pH at 25 0C
:
9.8 to 10.8
2
Phosphate Residual (as PO4)
:
20 to 40 (If Added)
3
Total Dissolved Solids, Max. (T.D.S.)           mg/L
:
3500
4
Specified Electrical Conductivity at 25 0C, Max. Microsiemens/ cm
:
7000
5
Total Alkalinity                                         mg/L
:
700



 

0 comments:

Post a Comment